Metavid

Video archive of the US Congress

House Proceeding on Mar 11th, 2009 :: 0:49:10 to 1:09:10
Total video length: 2 hours 5 minutes Stream Tools: Stream Overview | Edit Time

Note: MetaVid video transcripts may contain inaccuracies, help us build a more perfect archive

Download OptionsEmbed Video

Views:1,374 Duration: 0:20:00 Discussion

Previous speech: Next speech:

Jason Altmire

0:46:45 to 0:49:10( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Jason Altmire

Jason Altmire

0:48:49 to 0:49:10( Edit History Discussion )

Jason Altmire: trails in title 5 and heritage areas in title 8. this ensures that nothing in these sections of the bill shall regulate hunting, fishing, and trapping or limit their access to these public lands. my amendment is straightforward and simple. it's supported by the n.r.a. and with its inclusion i urge my colleagues, especially

John Abney Culberson

0:49:11 to 0:49:31( Edit History Discussion )

John Abney Culberson: supporters of the second amendment, to vote in favor of this public lands bill today. i yield back the balance of my time. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman yields back the balance of his time. the gentleman from washington. mr. hastings: mr. speaker, i'm pleased to yield two minutes t the gentleman from texas, mr. cull bervon. -- culberson. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from texas is recognized for two minutes.

John Abney Culberson

0:49:15 to 0:53:05( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: John Abney Culberson

John Abney Culberson

0:49:32 to 0:49:52( Edit History Discussion )

John Abney Culberson: mr. culberson: here again on this house floor a 1,294-page bill has been dropped on to the american people with no committee hearing, not even a rules committee hearing, spendi $10 billion. the arrogance of power of speaker pelosi -- nancy pelosi's beginning to remind me of marie antoinette. with her attitude towards the

John Abney Culberson

0:49:53 to 0:50:14( Edit History Discussion )

John Abney Culberson: people of france she couldn't be driven around paris in anything but the very finest carriages. the contempt that the leadership of this congress has for the american people's input for transparency -- mr. rahall: mr. speaker, parliamentary inquiry. the speaker pro tempore: would the gentleman yield.

John Abney Culberson

0:50:15 to 0:50:36( Edit History Discussion )

John Abney Culberson: mr. rahall: i ask the gentleman's words be taken down. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman will suspend. the clerk will report the words. the gentleman from texas will

John Abney Culberson

0:50:37 to 0:50:49( Edit History Discussion )

John Abney Culberson: take his seat. the speaker pro tempore: the chair will recommend to the chairman from texas to take his seat. the gentleman from texas is

John Abney Culberson

0:51:21 to 0:51:42( Edit History Discussion )

John Abney Culberson: asked to take his seat. the speaker pro tempore: for what purpose does the gentleman from texas rise? mr. culberson: i ask unanimous consent to withdraw the remarks. withdraw my remarks. the speaker pro tempore: is there objection? without objection, so ordered. mr. culberson: mr. speaker, it is important, however, that this house of representatives represent the people. and do so in a way that does not demonstrate contempt for the opinion of the people.

John Abney Culberson

0:51:43 to 0:52:03( Edit History Discussion )

John Abney Culberson: a 1,294-page bill, mr. speaker, has been dropped on the floor without regard for committee hearings, without regard for transparency, without regard to the promise that this leadership made to be the most transparent, open, and accountable congress in the history of the united states. spending $10 billion that our children do not have. that is a complete violation of

John Abney Culberson

0:52:04 to 0:52:24( Edit History Discussion )

John Abney Culberson: all the promises made by this leadership to the people. and look at the bill that they are passing. this piece of legislation will make a criminal out of every tourist traveling the western university who makes the mistake of picking up a rock and throwing it in their trunk, grandma and grandpa are going to be thrown in jail if they -- read from the bill, if you don't believe me.

John Abney Culberson

0:52:25 to 0:52:45( Edit History Discussion )

John Abney Culberson: if you don't have a permit, if you're not a qualified paleontologist, and you pick up a rock a throw it in the car, if you alter a rock on federally owned land, most of the western states, and throw it in the car it is five years in prison, page 526 of the bill, five years in prison for putting the rock in the trunk. vehicle confiscated.

John Abney Culberson

0:52:46 to 0:53:05( Edit History Discussion )

John Abney Culberson: turn to page 531, all vehicles and equipment shall be subject to civil forfeiture. ladies and gentlemen of the congress, if you vote for this bill, you're voting to subject your constituents to be thrown in jail, grandma and grandpa with the grandkids traveling in the western states if they pick up a rock and throw it in the car, five years in jail,

Nick J. Rahall

0:53:06 to 0:53:26( Edit History Discussion )

Nick J. Rahall: thousands of dollars in fines, and the winnebago will be confiscated. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. the gentleman from west virginia. mr. rahall: mr. speaker, i think previous colloquies or language at least put into this debate by the gentleman from texas, mr. smith, made it very clear that it's not the intent of the sponsors of this legislation to see innocent civilians

Nick J. Rahall

0:53:10 to 0:53:30( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Nick J. Rahall

Nick J. Rahall

0:53:27 to 0:53:30( Edit History Discussion )

Nick J. Rahall: collting fossils on public lands go to jail. that's not the intent.

Jim Costa

0:53:31 to 0:53:51( Edit History Discussion )

Jim Costa: it's been made very clear both in the legislation and already in this debate thus far. i yield for unanimous consent to the distinguished gentleman of our energy and mineral subcommittee, mr. costa from california. the sp gentleman is recognized. mr. costa: i thank the gentleman for yielding. i ask unanimous consent to revise and extend.

Jim Costa

0:53:35 to 0:53:50( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Jim Costa

Grace F. Napolitano

0:53:52 to 0:54:12( Edit History Discussion )

Grace F. Napolitano: on this legislation s. 22. the speaker pro tempore: without objection, so ordered mr. the distinguished gentlelady from california, our superb chairman, subcommittee chair of our water resources subcommittee, ms. grace napolitano, for two minutes. the speaker pro tempore: the gentlelady is recognized for two minutes. mrs. napolitano: allow me to speak in support of senate bill

Grace F. Napolitano

0:53:55 to 0:55:50( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Grace F. Napolitano

Grace F. Napolitano

0:54:13 to 0:54:34( Edit History Discussion )

Grace F. Napolitano: 22, omnibus public lands management act of 2009 within which are 30 separate authorizations for the bureau of reclamation and united states geological the bills include and highlight the changing western water environment. the bill authorizes conservation, water use efficiencies, and water recycling projects.

Grace F. Napolitano

0:54:35 to 0:54:55( Edit History Discussion )

Grace F. Napolitano: addresses aging infrastructure issues, and allows for the asibilitstudy of many much need water projects. our subcommittee of water and power heard most of these bills and were approved unanimously by both sides. seven, california title 16 re-authorizations and two ground

Grace F. Napolitano

0:54:56 to 0:55:16( Edit History Discussion )

Grace F. Napolitano: water recharge authorizations are included in this bill. when completed these projects will produce 500,000 acre of feet of reclaimed, reused water in added storage capacity. there are many areas of drought in the western states, including in my home state of california,

Grace F. Napolitano

0:55:17 to 0:55:38( Edit History Discussion )

Grace F. Napolitano: which is now facing its third unprecedented drought year. title 16 projects would allow for communities to expand their local water resources and lessen their reliance on unreliable imported water supplies. finally, this legislation will ratify two tribal water right settments in nevada and new

Grace F. Napolitano

0:55:39 to 0:55:51( Edit History Discussion )

Grace F. Napolitano: mexico and set a funding mechanism for many others across the west t will resolve many years of litigation and bring "peace in the valley" for tribal and nontribal communities.

Paul Braun, Jr.

0:55:52 to 0:56:12( Edit History Discussion )

Paul Braun, Jr.: i might add this was on a bipartisan basis out of committee at all times. i yield back. the speaker pro tempore: the gentlelady yields back her time. the gentleman from washington. mr. hastings: mr. speaker, i'm pleased to yield one minute to the gentleman from georgia, mr. broun, a member of the committee. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from georgia is

Paul Braun, Jr.

0:55:55 to 0:57:40( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Paul Braun, Jr.

Paul Braun, Jr.

0:56:13 to 0:56:33( Edit History Discussion )

Paul Braun, Jr.: recognized for one minute. mr. broun: political philosopher, stated that the preservation of property is the reason for which men enter into society. and that no government hath the right to take their property or any part of it without their own

Paul Braun, Jr.

0:56:34 to 0:56:55( Edit History Discussion )

Paul Braun, Jr.: consent. for this would be in effect to leave them no property at all. our nation is facing an economic crisis. yet democrats are forng this chamber to rush through the omnibus or should i say ominous lands bill. today they will increase

Paul Braun, Jr.

0:56:56 to 0:57:16( Edit History Discussion )

Paul Braun, Jr.: government spending by as much as $10 billion and permanently lock up tens of millions of acres of the people's land. the federal government already owns over 650 million acres of land that it can't take care of. the national park service alone faces a backlog of $9 million worth of projects that need to be funded.

Paul Braun, Jr.

0:57:17 to 0:57:38( Edit History Discussion )

Paul Braun, Jr.: if s. 22 were to pass, there will be more wilderness acres in the united states than the total amount of developed land. it is a huge attack on people's rights and especially property rights. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman's time has expired. mr. hastings: i yield 15 seconds. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman is recognized for an additional 15 seconds. mr. broun: it is not the role of

Paul Braun, Jr.

0:57:39 to 0:57:41( Edit History Discussion )

Paul Braun, Jr.: the federal government to hoard masses amounts of land.

Mike Thompson

0:57:42 to 0:58:02( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Thompson: i urge my on s. 22. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman yields back the balance of his time. the gentleman from west virginia. mr. rahall: i yield one minute to the gentleman from california, mr the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman is recognized for one minute. mr. thompson: i thank the gentleman for all the good work he did on this bill and ask we internear a colloquy on this bill. mr. chairman, as you know the

Mike Thompson

0:57:45 to 0:58:35( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Mike Thompson

Mike Thompson

0:58:03 to 0:58:23( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Thompson: trinitriver is the largest trib by tear to the klamath river and key to helping restore salmon and steelhead stocks along the entire pacific coast. the federal government has a responsibility to the hoopa valley indian tribe and the sport and commercial fishers to restore the fisheries of this great and important river. i respectfully request the chairman's cooperation in

Mike Thompson

0:58:24 to 0:58:36( Edit History Discussion )

Mike Thompson: working with the new administration and the appropriations committee to help secure the adequate funding need to restore the trinity river to ameliorate any lost

Nick J. Rahall

0:58:37 to 0:58:55( Edit History Discussion )

Nick J. Rahall: costs associate implementation of the san joaquin settlement within this bill. mr. rahall: i'm mindful of and remain implementing the restotion record decision, restoring the fishery restoreses of the trinity river is important for the tribe. commercial, and recreational

Nick J. Rahall

0:58:40 to 0:58:55( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Nick J. Rahall

Rob Bishop

0:58:56 to 0:59:16( Edit History Discussion )

Rob Bishop: fishing valleys along the coast of california and oregon. i agree to work with the gentleman from california in this regard. mr. thompson: i thank you very much. i yield back the balance of my time. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman yields bacthe balance of his time. the gentleman from washington. mr. hastings: thank you, mr. speaker. mr. speaker, i'm pleased to yield fufe minutes to a very valuable member of the natural resources gentleman from utah, mr. bishop. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from utah is

Rob Bishop

0:59:00 to 1:04:15( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Rob Bishop

Rob Bishop

0:59:17 to 0:59:38( Edit History Discussion )

Rob Bishop: recognized for five minutes. mr. bishop: thank you, mr. speaker. when i was teaching government, i taught my kids thaa suspension was one of those noncontroversial bills for which it could be brought to the floor with a limited amount of debate and no opportunity for amendments. we have today a suspension that is over 1 over half of which have never been discussed in either the

Rob Bishop

0:59:39 to 0:59:59( Edit History Discussion )

Rob Bishop: house or floor committee meeting until this morning. 23 were never discussed in any committee hearing over in the senate. when the true cost is extrapolated out over the time of the authorization, it will be close to $8 billion to $10 billion. and 37 times the description of provisions in this bill were calledontroversial. but that's ok. this is a suspension.

Rob Bishop

1:00:00 to 1:00:20( Edit History Discussion )

Rob Bishop: doesn't matter that this bill has been criticized by the american motorcycle association for taking millions of acres of land out of the use for millions of people who want to use recreation. . or have been criticized by the u.s. chamber of commerce. even espn criticized this bill.

Rob Bishop

1:00:21 to 1:00:42( Edit History Discussion )

Rob Bishop: that's ok. it's a suspension. we are told that there's a $9 billion backlog in needs to the national parks. in the stimulus bill, apparently $2 billion were put in there to meet the needs of the national park and now we exacerbate the problem it by $9 billion in this particular bill. this is the visitor's center of

Rob Bishop

1:00:43 to 1:01:04( Edit History Discussion )

Rob Bishop: the national dinosaur museum in utah. this is a brillianplace to go. a kid can see within the mountainside, the foss else there -- the fossels in there. nobody has been able to access this building for 10 years because we don't have the money

Rob Bishop

1:01:05 to 1:01:25( Edit History Discussion )

Rob Bishop: to fix this building which has been condemned. rather than fixing these types of buildings, within the bow of this bill, there is a bill to protect such natural wonders such as a condominium, a butterfly garden and a microbrewry, a park that was

Rob Bishop

1:01:26 to 1:01:46( Edit History Discussion )

Rob Bishop: not requested by the national park service or not re by the national park service. we are putting billions of dollars in here while parks like this go vacant. and it's ok. this is still a supplement. we'll spend $110 million on heritage areas. 11 lucky heritage areas will

Rob Bishop

1:01:47 to 1:02:07( Edit History Discussion )

Rob Bishop: get federal money to assist them in economic development and tourism development. if you don't happen to live in those lucky 11 areas you'lle losing tourists and losing economic development and having the wonderful opportunity to have your taxes pay for that approach. rough economic times like we have, this is brilliant policy by us. it's ok. it's still a suspension.

Rob Bishop

1:02:08 to 1:02:29( Edit History Discussion )

Rob Bishop: falls river in massachusetts will have the lower taunten declared a wild and scenic river. the wild and scenic river act was there to protect areas from development. by laws and statute you can't have anything but a neatful builder within a mile of a wild and scenic river.

Rob Bishop

1:02:30 to 1:02:51( Edit History Discussion )

Rob Bishop: i went off about showing ugly pictures of falls river, massachusetts. shouldn't have done it. it's actually a pretty community. and they came back and showed pretty pictures of falls river, massachusetts. the point is it doesn't matter if there are ugly pictures or pretty pictures. doesn't matter if you think it's a cynical matter of stopping production of some

Rob Bishop

1:02:52 to 1:03:12( Edit History Discussion )

Rob Bishop: sort or thi this is for economic development. regardless if you take any of those stands, the purpose of that is not a wild and scenic river. these are not needful buildings within a half mile of the bank. while you look at that issue, it violates the spirit and the let ert of the wild and scenic river act and it violates more

Rob Bishop

1:03:13 to 1:03:33( Edit History Discussion )

Rob Bishop: than that. it simply says the rule of law can be pulled apart. anytime a jority comes on the floor and decides to vote for an issue that can now replace the standards of which we decide to deal with. we have a problem with the great obstacles to our border patrol and security. within the bows of this bill is another bill which will make it more difficult for border

Rob Bishop

1:03:34 to 1:03:55( Edit History Discussion )

Rob Bishop: security even on bicycles to try and patrol federal lands. those are problems within this structure and we're told it's still a suspension. we have about 12 members i counted on the floor engaging in this debate. soon there will be 400 more coming through these doors withouhaving heard the discussion, without having heard the debate and thinking

Rob Bishop

1:03:56 to 1:04:15( Edit History Discussion )

Rob Bishop: is nothing more than a suspension. we do need regular order. now, i want it very clear, not only do i not own monkeys but mr. rahall is not to blame for this. chairman rahall has done a perfect job on the house. even in the bad bills he has brought forward he at least went through regular order. this is a byproduct of the senate.

Nick J. Rahall

1:04:16 to 1:04:37( Edit History Discussion )

Nick J. Rahall: this is a product of the senate and the senate should be ashamed to try and compile 177 different bills into one omnibus package. and we should be ashamed of actually debating it as a suspension. i yield back. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman yields back the balance of his time. the gentleman from west virginia. mr. rahall: mr. speaker, i'd like the omnibus lands packages of the past by republican

Nick J. Rahall

1:04:20 to 1:04:45( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Nick J. Rahall

Nick J. Rahall

1:04:38 to 1:04:45( Edit History Discussion )

Nick J. Rahall: congress that are jammed down our throats at the last minute, this bill has been here well over a year in our committee. and to have the bill described as being jammed down our

George Miller

1:04:46 to 1:05:06( Edit History Discussion )

George Miller: throats at this point, the gentleman from utah has been in ite a few battles with this bill. so he must know a lot about it. i yield one minute to the gentleman from california, the distinguished chairman of our education and labor committee, mr. george miller. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman from california is recognized for one minute. lorraine c. miller i thank the gentleman for yielding and for bringing this -- mr. miller: i

George Miller

1:04:50 to 1:06:20( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: George Miller

George Miller

1:05:07 to 1:05:28( Edit History Discussion )

George Miller: thank the gentleman from for yielding and for bringing this bill to the floor. for total 16 of the reclamation act for water recycling and reuse. the products in this bill are very good districts. it's most important as we enter again the third year of this drought with continued stress put on all of the water systems throughout the west and

George Miller

1:05:29 to 1:05:49( Edit History Discussion )

George Miller: southwest that we get into recycling and reuses that will allow communities to take control of their water resources, to be more efficient in the use of them and allows us to develop. just in this legislation alone, if there's money in the stimulus for this, there is money in the appropriations bill for this. we're seeing a savings of about half a million to a million

George Miller

1:05:50 to 1:06:10( Edit History Discussion )

George Miller: acre-feet of water in the west. that's real water. it's valuable water, and we have the alt to reuse it. i thank the gentleman for this legislation and to the subcommittee chair, mrs. napolitano, a water champion of water recyclin i

George Miller

1:06:11 to 1:06:20( Edit History Discussion )

George Miller: say this saves the water in new jersey. i yield back. the speaker pro tempore: the gentleman yields back the balance of his time. the gentleman from washington. mr. hastings: how much time is

Cynthia Lummis

1:06:21 to 1:06:41( Edit History Discussion )

Cynthia Lummis: left on both sides? the speake minute and a half for mr. haste. 7 3/4 for mr. rahall. 5 1/2 for you. mr. hastings: i'm pleased to yield to theentlelady from wyoming, a new member of the committee. the speaker pro tempore: the gentlelady is recognized for two minutes. mrs. lummis: i beg of your indulgence of my voice this

Cynthia Lummis

1:06:35 to 1:08:50( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Cynthia Lummis

Cynthia Lummis

1:06:42 to 1:07:02( Edit History Discussion )

Cynthia Lummis: morning but this is a very important issue to me. i rise to oppose senate 22, the omnibus public land management act in a suspension. but my decision to oppose this was not an easy one because two of the individual bills in this omnibus measure were introduced in honor of a dear friend of mine, one of the truest western statesman to have ever served

Cynthia Lummis

1:07:03 to 1:07:23( Edit History Discussion )

Cynthia Lummis: in the united states congress. i speak of of course of the late senator craig thomas who is also a member of this body. a tireless advocate and protector of those values that continue to shape wyoming and its people. wyoming is a state blessed with from spectacular mountain

Cynthia Lummis

1:07:24 to 1:07:45( Edit History Discussion )

Cynthia Lummis: ranges to wide open plains, to the vast mineral deposits that lie beneath them. in wyoming, we find balance regarding how those varied resources are managed. the bill we are considering today fails in achieving that balance. while our economy reels and the federal deficit reaches record highs, this bill places an

Cynthia Lummis

1:07:46 to 1:08:07( Edit History Discussion )

Cynthia Lummis: additional $10 billion burden on the taxpayers in wyoming and across the nation. these are not dollars being spent to ease economic woes or create jobs. these are dollars being spent in largeart to restrict access to our public lands, to limit responsible energy production in the west and to

Cynthia Lummis

1:08:08 to 1:08:28( Edit History Discussion )

Cynthia Lummis: codify the vague and ill-conceived national landscape conservation system. supporters of this massive omnibus package will tell you that most of the bills are comprised of are largely noncontroversial and in some cases they are correct. but in many cases they are not. nearly 100 of the bills wrapped

Cynthia Lummis

1:08:29 to 1:08:50( Edit History Discussion )

Cynthia Lummis: into this measure were never considered by the full house. let alone by those of us who are freshmen. absolutely no amendments are allowed to be offered today. as such, i am afforded no opportunity to work with the people of my state to address the specific local concerns regarding the wyoming portion of this package.

Martin Heinrich

1:08:51 to 1:09:11( Edit History Discussion )

Martin Heinrich: the speaker pro tempore: the gentlelady has 15 additional seconds. mrs. lummis: thank you. in today's vote we're to choose all or nothing. i know, mr. speaker, we can do better. our public lands deserves better. i yield back the balance of my time. the speaker pro tempore: the gentle balance of her time. the gentleman from west virginia.

Martin Heinrich

1:08:55 to 1:10:20( Edit History Discussion )
Speech By: Martin Heinrich

Personal tools

MetaVid is a non-profit project of UC Santa Cruz and the Sunlight Foundation. Learn more About MetaVid

The C-SPAN logo and other servicemarks that may be found in video content are the property of their respective trademark holders. None of these trademark holders are affiliated with Metavid